Home / What we buy / Silver coins and sterling
Selling silver coins and sterling in Indianapolis
Rolls of silver halves, jars of old dimes and quarters, Morgan and Peace dollars and sterling flatware. Sorted, weighed and priced on the live silver market.
Silver we buy
- Dimes, quarters and halves from 1964 and earlier
- Kennedy halves from 1965 to 1970
- Morgan and Peace dollars
- Silver war nickels
- Sterling flatware and serving pieces
- Silver bars and rounds
- Canadian silver coins
How silver is priced
Ninety percent coins hold about seven tenths of an ounce of pure silver for each dollar of face value. Better dates come out first, then the rest is weighed and priced against live silver.
Sterling is weighed after we subtract steel blades and weighted bases.
Silver in Indy households
When the Mint switched to clad coins in 1965, plenty of Indianapolis families started setting aside every silver coin that came through their hands. Rolls of Franklin and Kennedy halves were especially popular, and we still see them in bank wrappers from Indiana National and Merchants National.
Sterling flatware from wedding registries at L. S. Ayres and William H. Block turns up in nearly every estate we see.
Silver chart
How to sort your change at a glance.
- Dimes, quarters and halves dated 1964 or earlier: 90 percent
- Kennedy halves from 1965 to 1970: 40 percent
- Nickels from 1942 to 1945 with a big mint mark over Monticello: 35 percent
- Morgan and Peace dollars: 90 percent
- Canadian coins through 1966: 80 percent
Silver dollars
Morgan and Peace dollars each hold about three quarters of a troy ounce of silver. Worn common dates sell modestly above that. Carson City dollars, the 1893-S, 1895, 1921 high relief Peace and 1928 Peace dollars deserve real attention. We grade each one that might carry a premium.
Sterling patterns
Central Indiana estates hold sterling from Gorham, Towle, Wallace, International and Reed and Barton. A full service for twelve often weighs well over a hundred troy ounces. We weigh solid pieces, estimate the silver in hollow handles and price the total at the live rate.
Weighted and hollow pieces
Candlesticks, compotes and some trays are thin silver over pitch or plaster, and hollow-handle knives are mostly steel. Only the silver gets paid for, and we walk you through how we figured it.
Halves in bank rolls
A roll of halves holds 20 coins, or ten dollars face. A roll of 90 percent halves holds a little over seven troy ounces of silver, and a roll of 40 percent Kennedys holds about three. Keep rolls closed until the visit, since original rolls occasionally hold brilliant coins worth more than silver.
GuideFranklin half dollar valuesAsk for a free appraisal
We return every call the same day and set a private time.
FAQ
Frequently asked
Are Kennedy halves silver?
1964 halves are 90 percent silver. 1965 to 1970 halves are 40 percent. Later ones are clad.
Do you buy silver dollars?
Yes. Morgan and Peace dollars are always welcome.
Is silver plate worth anything?
Very little. We test anything unclear and tell you.