Skip to content
Indianapolis Coin BuyerCoins, gold and silver

Home / What we buy / Estates and inherited collections

Selling an inherited collection in Indianapolis

When a parent leaves coins, old bills, gold or silver behind, we go through all of it with the family and write down every piece.

Cigar box of mixed coins from an Indiana farmhouse

What turns up in Indiana estates

  • Coin folders and proof sets
  • Rolls of silver halves
  • Silver certificates and old bills
  • Gold coins from safes
  • Class rings and gold jewelry
  • Sterling flatware
  • Silver dollars

How we price an estate

We go lot by lot. Metal is priced on weight and tested purity, collector coins and bills on grade and recent sales, and modern coins at face.

The written list covers everything, so heirs in Indianapolis and out of state see the same numbers.

Estates in Central Indiana

Central Indiana estates often include a farmhouse or an older city home with a full basement, and coins turn up in odd places: a canning jar on a shelf, an old toolbox, a coffee can in the barn. Walk the whole property before an auction company comes.

Many heirs live in Illinois, Ohio or farther away. We meet whoever is in town and email the list to everyone else.

First steps

Gather everything in one room. Check closets, dresser drawers, the basement, the barn, the freezer and any bank box. Leave coins in their holders and bills in their envelopes.

  • Bring coins and bills up from damp basements
  • Do not clean, iron or sort
  • Keep any receipts and old lists
  • Decide on keepsakes first

Before the auction company

Estate auctions in Indiana often sell coins in mixed lots that hide the good pieces. Have coins, bills and gold priced first, so you know what they are worth before anything goes on a sale table.

Dividing among heirs

Siblings often worry about dividing things fairly. With weights and prices on one sheet, the family can split pieces by value, or sell the lot and divide the proceeds.

Executors and paperwork

Probate does not have to be finished for us to take a look. A free appraisal gives the personal representative numbers for the inventory. When it is time to sell, bring whatever document names who can sign, and we pay that person or the estate account.

Farm estates

Indiana farm families hid valuables well. We have seen silver dollars in canning jars on basement shelves, gold coins taped under drawers and bills folded inside old feed sacks. If the family suspects something is hidden, look before the property sells.

Savings bonds and other papers

Estates often hold old savings bonds, stock certificates and bank books alongside coins. We do not buy those, but we will set them aside and point out anything that looks like it still has value, so nothing gets thrown out by accident.

GuideSilver certificate values

Ask for a free appraisal

We return every call the same day and set a private time.

Add a description (optional)

FAQ

Frequently asked

Do all heirs need to be present?

No. Relatives who cannot make it get the list by email.

Do you come to farms?

Yes. Give us the county road or nearest town when you call.

Can we keep some pieces?

Yes. Anything kept stays off the offer.