Skip to content
Indianapolis Coin BuyerCoins, gold and silver

Home / What we buy / Gold coins

Selling gold coins in Indianapolis

Pre-1933 American gold, modern bullion coins and gold from around the world. Weighed, measured and priced with gold value and premium side by side.

U.S. gold coins

Gold coins we buy

  • Double eagles, Liberty and Saint-Gaudens
  • Eagles, half eagles and quarter eagles
  • Gold dollars
  • American Gold Eagles and Buffalos
  • Krugerrands and Maple Leafs
  • Sovereigns and other world gold
  • Certified gold

How gold coins are priced

Each coin starts from its gold content at today's spot price. Bullion coins sell close to that. Pre-1933 U.S. gold almost always trades higher.

Scarce dates, better mint marks and high grades add the most. On the offer, each coin is its own entry.

Gold coins in Central Indiana

Indiana farm families held on to gold coins through the 1933 recall more often than city families did, and many of those coins came out of hiding only in the 1970s. Others were bought by Indianapolis professionals as savings after 1975, when Americans could own gold again.

We see a lot of Philadelphia and San Francisco double eagles, plus Gold Eagles and Krugerrands bought over the last forty years.

Signs a gold coin is worth more

Pre-1933 gold brings the biggest premiums when it shows little wear, original luster and a less common mint mark. Look on the back for CC, O, D or C. Carson City, New Orleans, Dahlonega and Charlotte coins are scarcer than Philadelphia and San Francisco coins. Never clean a gold coin; fine cleaning scratches cut value sharply.

Bullion coins we see most

These modern coins sell near their gold value.

  • American Gold Eagles in all four sizes
  • American Gold Buffalos
  • South African Krugerrands
  • Canadian Maple Leafs
  • Austrian Philharmonics
  • Mexican 50 pesos

Certified gold

Coins in PCGS or NGC holders are priced on the label grade and recent sales at that grade. We verify each certification number before pricing.

Holding some back

Families often keep a gold coin for each grandchild and sell the rest. Every coin is listed separately, so you pick which ones go.

Commemorative gold

Modern U.S. commemorative gold coins from 1984 on, in five and ten dollar sizes, hold a quarter or half ounce of gold. Older commemorative gold dollars from the early 1900s, like the Louisiana Purchase and Lewis and Clark issues, are scarcer and sell to collectors well above their small gold content.

GuideFranklin half dollar values

Ask for a free appraisal

We return every call the same day and set a private time.

Add a description (optional)

FAQ

Frequently asked

Is my gold coin real?

We check weight, size and metal without leaving a mark. Fakes do turn up, so every coin gets checked.

Do you buy gold coins in jewelry?

Yes. The coin and the mount are weighed and priced separately.

Do you buy fractional Gold Eagles?

Yes. Each size is priced on exactly the gold it holds.