Skip to content
Indianapolis Coin BuyerCoins, gold and silver

Home / What we buy / Old coins and collections

Selling old coins in Indianapolis

Blue folders, cigar boxes, rolls from the bank and proof sets ordered by mail every year. We check each coin, set aside the scarce ones and tell you which are common.

Album of old American coins

Coins we buy

  • Indian Head and wheat cents
  • Buffalo and war nickels
  • Mercury and Roosevelt silver dimes
  • Washington silver quarters
  • Walking Liberty, Franklin and Kennedy halves
  • Morgan and Peace dollars
  • Proof and mint sets

How old coins are priced

U.S. silver coins from 1964 and earlier are always worth at least their silver. Copper and nickel coins begin at face. Date, mint and condition move coins above those floors.

We list the better coins one by one with grade and price, and group the rest by type with a count.

Collections from Hoosier homes

A lot of Indianapolis collections started at a bank teller window. In the 1950s and 1960s, kids bought rolls of cents and nickels at banks along Washington Street, searched them for dates and filled Whitman folders. Factory workers at Allison, Chrysler and RCA did the same with silver change.

Those folders and rolls are surfacing now in estates from Speedway to Irvington. Most hold common coins, but nearly every one has a few worth pulling.

Dates that get a second look

Most coins in a folder are common. These get checked twice.

  • 1909-S VDB, 1914-D, 1922 plain and 1931-S wheat cents
  • 1877 and 1909-S Indian Head cents
  • 1913-S Type 2 and 1937-D three-legged buffalo nickels
  • 1916-D and 1921 Mercury dimes
  • 1932-D and 1932-S Washington quarters
  • 1938-D and 1921 Walking Liberty halves

Where mint marks hide

On Lincoln cents the mint mark sits below the date. On buffalo nickels it is on the back under FIVE CENTS. Mercury dimes carry it on the back near the base of the bundle of rods, and Walking Liberty halves on the back at lower left. Philadelphia coins usually have none. There is no need to look ahead of time, since we check each coin anyway.

Basement and barn storage

Indiana basements stay damp, and barns swing from freezing to hot. Copper darkens or turns green, cardboard folders warp and paper rolls stain. Do not try to clean anything. Bring coins upstairs, let them dry and bring them exactly as they are.

Proof and mint sets

Sets from 1964 and earlier hold 90 percent silver coins. Special mint sets from 1965, 1966 and 1967 each carry one 40 percent silver half. Most clad sets after 1968 sell for close to face, while silver proof sets from 1992 on carry silver. Keep every set in the envelope or case it came in.

Two-cent pieces and half dimes

Older collections sometimes hold coins from before 1900: two-cent pieces, three-cent pieces, half dimes, seated Liberty silver and large cents. These are less common in folders but turn up in cigar boxes from old Indiana families. Most carry collector value well above face.

Indiana state quarters and modern coins

The 2002 Indiana state quarter, with its race car and nineteen stars, was saved by the million, along with the rest of the 50 State Quarters. Circulated state quarters are worth face. Rolls and modern commemoratives in silver are another matter, and we check those for metal value.

GuideBuffalo nickel values

Ask for a free appraisal

We return every call the same day and set a private time.

Add a description (optional)

FAQ

Frequently asked

Are my wheat pennies worth anything?

Most are worth a few cents. The 1909-S VDB, the 1914-D and a handful of other dates are the exceptions, and they bring real money.

Do you buy proof sets?

Yes. Sets with silver coins carry silver value, and a few years carry premiums.

Should I clean my coins first?

No. Cleaning lowers the value.