Home / What we buy / Old paper money
Selling old paper money in Indianapolis
Blue-seal silver certificates, yellow-seal gold certificates, national bank notes printed for Indiana banks and the big bills from before 1929. Each note checked for series, condition and rarity.
Paper money we buy
- Silver certificates from 1886 to 1957
- Gold certificates
- National bank notes from Indiana banks
- Large-size notes from before 1929
- Star notes and fancy serial numbers
- Hawaii and North Africa wartime notes
- Fractional currency
How paper money is priced
Paper money is priced on series, signatures, rarity and condition. Folds, tears, stains and missing corners all lower value, while crisp notes with original paper bring the most.
Most small-size silver certificates from 1935 and 1957 sell for a little over face. Older and scarcer notes can bring far more, and we explain why on the list.
Indiana bank notes
From 1863 to 1935, national banks across Indiana issued their own currency with the bank's name printed on the face. Notes from Fletcher National, Indiana National and dozens of small-town banks in Hamilton, Hendricks and Johnson counties are collected today, and small-town notes are often the scarcest.
We find old bills tucked into family Bibles, old wallets, cigar boxes and envelopes marked for grandchildren. Keep them flat and do not try to repair them.
Colors of the seal
The seal color tells you what kind of note you have.
- Blue seal: silver certificate
- Red seal: United States note
- Gold or yellow seal: gold certificate, or North Africa wartime note
- Brown seal: national bank note, or Hawaii wartime note
- Green seal: Federal Reserve note, today's money
National bank notes in detail
National bank notes name the issuing bank and its charter number on the face. Collectors look for notes from small towns and banks that issued few notes, so a bill from a tiny bank in Hendricks or Hamilton County can be worth much more than one from a big Indianapolis bank. Signatures of the bank's officers are often handwritten or stamped on older notes.
Large-size notes
Before 1929, U.S. paper money was about 25 percent larger than today. Collectors call these horse blankets. Large-size silver certificates, gold certificates, national bank notes and United States notes all carry premiums, and some designs, like the 1896 Educational series, bring a lot.
Fractional currency
During and after the Civil War, the Treasury issued paper notes worth 3, 5, 10, 15, 25 and 50 cents because coins were being hoarded. These small notes turn up in family Bibles and old scrapbooks. Most sell for a few dollars to a few dozen.
What to leave alone
Do not iron, tape, wash or flatten notes under books. Do not remove them from old albums if they are glued in. Bring them as they are, and we look at each one carefully.
Star notes and serial numbers
A star next to the serial number marks a replacement note. Collectors also like low serial numbers, such as 00000012, and patterns like repeaters or ladders. Most modern bills are worth face, but a note with one of these features can bring more. We check every serial.
GuideSilver certificate valuesAsk for a free appraisal
We return every call the same day and set a private time.
FAQ
Frequently asked
What is a silver certificate worth?
Most 1935 and 1957 dollar notes sell for a little over face. Older series, star notes and crisp notes bring more.
Do you buy torn bills?
Yes. Damage lowers collector value, but many notes still sell above face.
Do you buy two-dollar bills?
Older red-seal and large-size twos carry premiums. Modern ones are worth face.